कुछ कह दिया होता?
कूर्ग का टिकट करा ही लिया होता?
शायद सब बेहतर होता।
The “if theory” is the wisest of all for the pitch — even for skeptical humans.
Time traveling has always fascinated my mind, as it does for many of us. We often wish to leap into the future or alter the past.
Last July, I unexpectedly got a call from the city of Jhilmil and Barfi. I felt the emotions exactly as Satyajit Ray’s movies make us feel, with the metaphysical boundaries of dreams and reality, reminiscent of Nobel Laureate Rabindranath Tagore’s poetry. Before my rotting thoughts could steal all the joy, as they did in the movie Lootera near lakes, I tried to reassemble my gratitude while being in sujood.
Literature expertise would lead to an institute talking about consultancy. Phew! I never thought God’s pitch worked like that. If 25-year-old Munazza hadn’t heard that, she wouldn’t have thought of this pun:
What a joka!
No wonder I’ve stopped writing. Ideas only come in dreams, in waves, often butchered with Gen Z slang and the jargon of a plastered world. It reminds me how life moves fast: weather changes early, sickness comes early, love arrives early, so does separation; fog arrives early, so does chilliness; fraud becomes a trend, so does honesty.
Dreams knock unexpectedly, often when we least want visitors — like 10:10 a.m. I talk endlessly about anything and everything. Perhaps that’s why the interview felt so right a month before. It’s all from God — a dream I never even imagined living. God knows exactly where to place us on the map of qadr (destiny). What a brilliant planner!
The months pass like time in Christopher Nolan’s movies, or like protons when observed using discharged tubes during Eugen Goldstein's experiment in 1886. The tightness in my chest was real when September arrived, yet I laughed while discussing Oedipus and Homer in Professor Nandita’s class in August 2025, just as I had in Professor Vaishali’s Delhi class in 2016 during my first dive into Classical European Literature. Nine years later, the cycle completed itself, surpassing the curtain of reality.
The past is mushy and chipchipi; reality is wet like rain: calm, and in control. Emotions hang like a fragile bridge between the two. Just as the distance between two colonized cities: Bombay and Calcutta which remains stark, so has my perspective shifted. Yet, the lingering ‘sone ki chidiya’ past still whispers. August ended with our students drenched in talent and the anxiety of the Managerial Communication-1 Public Speaking Examination, with Executive Ethics being observed under the watchful eye of an owl. If we deconstruct it the paragraph simply talks how memories and moments move in non-linear narratives.
I sit back and watch all the places that gave my sinus pain a pause while compiling videos, and it reminded me how much I would have missed my lover: if I ever had one. I imagined writing to him about these places while wrapping fresh candies and crafts from land where colonisers first landed.
While writing the next person’s reel appeared: my favorite letter from Richard Feynman being recited. Making me realise how most experiments end with one simple truth,
it’s just you and your happy endingssss in the post real world (a whole of imagination)!
We can’t capture people in reality (legally or metaphorically) without crushing them under our care, turning us into the character of Shahrukh from Darr, or, in alternative verse, bringing the dark edges of our psyche into play telling we are all psychopath in some ways. Life balances rationality and poetic justice with astonishing precision. Meaning, life just knows how to balance everything.
I’m glad art exists! a space where we can breathe our pain, fear, and gratitude, and share the collective consciousness of being vulnerable as a human. A fragile human like me(and like all of us) may ache to the core, yet still sleeps each night with unshaken hope that tomorrow’s sunshine will bring their K... K... K... K... Kirannnnn... not as a bullet tearing through skin, but as a quiet boat gliding toward Lake Como, where no Creative Associate or Elite Consultancy is needed to nudge them about “and they lived happily ever after”or “the profit kept on increasing till the death of time."
Perhaps the biggest irony of the ‘if-theory’ is that we only think of it afterwards. In the moment, God has already played the move, and we are just catching up exactly like subtitles appearing half a second late, yet still making sense of the film.
Closing curtains both of my imagination and windows making sure the bleak ends this series of confusing what ifs!
❤️❤️❤️❤️
ReplyDelete✨🌟
DeleteYou always leave me speachless with you writings mingled with the reality, dreams and full of hopes and gratitude
ReplyDeleteHeart is filled with gratitude when words resonates. Thank you for your time for reading and reviewing it. ❤️✨
DeleteSomething floated from heart ❤️ to heart ❤️
ReplyDeleteThank you so much Akku❤️
DeleteMunazza, I truly loved reading this post, The way you began with the “if theory” instantly pulled me in, and it made me think of how often we all wish to change the past or look into the future,I didn’t want it to end, because every line had its own depth💯 When you wrote about July and the call from the city of Jhilmil and Barfi, it gave me that calm, dreamlike feeling, like being inside a Satyajit Ray film🫶
ReplyDeleteYour description of how life moves fast with love, separation, sickness, even weather felt so real and emotional🥹It made me reflect on how fragile yet powerful life is. I especially connected with the part where you mentioned time moving like a Christopher Nolan movie and the way your classes in 2025 brought back memories of 2016. That comparison of past and present was beautiful❣️
I also loved how you spoke about dreams, memories, and emotions as a fragile bridge🥹💯 It felt calming but also stirred a lot of thoughts about reality and pain. The way you weaved art, literature, philosophy, and even science experiments into your reflections made it so unique and layered🙌
The ending stayed with me the most your words about the ‘if-theory’ and God’s planning, like subtitles appearing a little late but still making sense, were just so powerful. It gave me peace and reminded me of hope, even through confusion and pain🫂
Reading this was like sitting with my own emotions 🥹calm, thoughtful, a little heavy at times, but full of meaning 💯It’s truly beautiful how you turned your experiences of July, August, and September into something that feels universal🫶🙌🌈💌
You’re hogging onto rasgullas while reading my least favourite work at least is the best start of this month. The morning rainfall and fresh breeze made me smile less than your words and emotions which you poured while writing this. 🌸 The audio notes you sent while reading it will always stay in the Starmarked galleries. Thank you for always being super cool. I love you more than the best diary you gifted me (I’m not kidding). 🤭🥰
Delete